Walt Disney was the recipient of 22 Oscars throughout his career, more than any other person who has worked in the entertainment industry. Since his passing in 1966, The Walt Disney Company has continued to receive Oscars for Animated Features and Live-Action Features, though throughout their 102-year-history, they have never won an Oscar for Best Picture, though there have been four films that were nominated. In tribute to the fact that the 97th Oscar Nominations are being announced this Friday, January 17th, 2025, I thought we could acknowledge those four films:
Mary Poppins, released on August 27th, 1964, was the first and only Disney film produced during Walt Disney’s life to receive a Best Picture Oscar Nomination. The film garnered 13 Oscar Nominations, and though it lost Best Picture to My Fair Lady (1964), it won five total, including Best Original Score, Best Original Song “Chim-Chim Cher-ee,” and Julie Andrews as Best Actress for her performance as the magical nanny. This win made Andrews the second actress to receive an Oscar for a Performance in a Disney film. The first was Hayley Mills who won the Juvenile Oscar for her performance in Pollyanna (1960). The Juvenile Oscar went out of existence at the Oscars three years later when Patty Duke was nominated for, and won the Best Supporting Actress Oscar for The Miracle Worker (1962), proving that child actors could compete against adults in the major categories.
Beauty and the Beast, released on November 22nd, 1991, made history for the Walt Disney Company when it became the very first animated feature ever to receive an Oscar Nomination for Best Picture. While it lost the award to The Silence of the Lambs (1991), it received six Oscar Nominations total, and coincidentally just like “Poppins,” it also won the Oscars for Best Original Score and Best Original Song “Beauty and the Beast.” (The movie also got nominations for Best Sound and the songs “Belle” and “Be Our Guest.”) “Beauty and the Beast” being nominated for Best Picture was also special for the Disney Company because Walt Disney had attempted to adapt the story for the screen twice in the ‘30s and the ‘50s, but sadly, neither of his attempts ever came to fruition. “Beauty and the Beast,” did win the Golden Globe for Best Picture Musical or Comedy and later became the very first Disney film to be adapted for the Broadway Stage when it premiered at New York City’s Palace Theatre on April, 18th, 1994.
Up, released on May 29th, 2009, became the very first Pixar Animated Feature to be nominated for Best Picture. It lost that year to the The Hurt Locker (2009), which also won Best Director for Kathryn Bigelow, making Bigelow the first woman every to win an Oscar for Best Director. Despite this, “Up” did receive the Oscars for Best Original Score, which was written by Michael Giacchino and Best Animated Feature for it’s co-screenwriter/co-director, Pete Docter. Docter later won the Best Animated Feature Oscars for writing/directing Inside Out (2015) and Soul (2020), and was also nominated for Monsters, Inc. (2001). Giacchino previously received a Best Original Score Nomination for Ratatouille (2007).
Toy Story 3, released on June 18th, 2010, is the fourth Disney film to be nominated for Best Picture, but once again it was not to be. It lost Best Picture to The King’s Speech (2010). Just like “Up” though, it won the Best Animated Feature Oscar as well as Best Original Song “We Belong Together,” written by Randy Newman. Toy Story 4 (2019), released nine years later, also received the Best Animated Feature Oscar. Fun Fact: All four “Toy Story” films have featured music by Randy Newman, who wrote songs that have been nominated for Best Original Song: “You’ve Got a Friend in Me” from Toy Story (1995), “When She Loved Me,” from Toy Story 2 (1999), “We Belong Together,” from “3” and “I Can’t Let You Throw Yourself Away,” from “4.”
While it is unfortunate that Disney has never won a Best Picture Oscar, I’m sure we can all agree that these four films won awards in other well-deserved categories. Whether or not there will be a Best Picture Win for Disney remains to be seen.